Nine o'clock on the morning of 30 October 2026 came and went on Nevis, and the money was not there. By that hour, under a court order carrying a penal notice to every one of its directors, BONI, the Bank of New Innovation, was to have paid out US$11,898,198.79 to the customers who had sued it, with damages in Eastern Caribbean dollars besides for two former members of its own staff, and US$3,418,296.83 of the dollar sum straight into the Registry of the High Court itself. As the deadline closed in, High Court staff confirmed that no funds had been placed into the Registry. A week later, an investigation by SecretsReporters finds no payment reported by anyone, no contempt application on the public record, no decision on the bank's licence, and not one word of any of it in any newspaper anywhere. The deadline passed in silence, and the bank trades on.
The orders were made on 15 September 2026 by Mr Justice Iain Morley KC of the High Court of Nevis, in a single omnibus judgment of 222 pages that swept up 39 sets of proceedings against the bank, with claims running above US$100 million. BONI was ordered to pay US$3,553,971.68 to ZNX Limited. It was ordered to pay US$3,017,909.88 into the Court for Selecta Insurance (Caribbean). It was ordered to pay US$400,386.95 into the Court for INE and CHx of Belize. It was ordered to pay US$1,809,529.37 to Arc Holdings Company LLC and Arc Star LLC, and US$3,116,400.91 to Trident Trust Company (Nevis) Limited as trustee of the Star Gate Trust. And it was ordered to pay damages of EC$304,479 to Yasmine Tyson-Hanley and EC$157,247.50 to Sandra Huggins, two of its own former employees. Every sum was to be paid by 09:00 on 30 October 2026.
The orders were not written as requests. They were endorsed with a penal notice directed to all of BONI's directors, the form of words by which a court warns named men and women that disobedience is contempt of court, punishable by prison. The judge who wrote them did not expect obedience. Reading the bank's years of evasion, the moved goalposts and the hearings its chief executive failed to attend, he set down his expectation in the judgment itself, that not a penny would be paid. The money that should have answered the orders had already travelled. The judgment records that funds belonging to the bank's customers had been moved out to Safra Bank in New York.
BONI is the former Bank of Nevis International, bought outright in 2019 by Petrodel, the oil trading business of Nigerian trader Michael J. Prest, and renamed the Bank of New Innovation in 2023 while keeping the old acronym. The judgment places the bank's control where its ownership sits: Prest at its head, his sister Helen Prest-Ajayi beside him, and its chief executive, Temitope Elusogbon, based in Lagos, an officer the judge found untruthful in his evidence. A Nigerian-owned bank on a Caribbean island, holding other people's millions, and answering to a Nevis court that had stopped believing it.
Hanley and Huggins were not investors who lost a speculation. They were members of the bank's own staff who complained about dishonesty inside it and were sacked for their trouble, in 2023. They sued for wrongful dismissal, won judgment in default when the bank did not answer, and their damages formed part of what fell due on 30 October. Their claim, the smallest money in the omnibus judgment, is the one that opened the bank's affairs to the court, because it was their case that required the judge to examine what had been going on inside BONI.
The same judgment did something no Nevis court had done to the bank before. It referred BONI to the Regulator of International Banking, Mr Phil Jones, and to the Premier of Nevis, Dr Mark Brantley, for the revocation or suspension of its banking licence under section 35 of the Nevis International Banking Ordinance. The Premier had already written to the bank on 6 August 2026. On the record before the court, the bank had filed no audited accounts for any year from 2021 to 2026, and it was given until 18 September 2026 to make representations against the loss of its licence. The court, having read the whole file, told the regulator and the Premier in terms that closure was the course it recommended.
None of it has visibly happened. Since 30 October there has been no gazette notice, no suspension, no revocation, no custodian appointed, and no statement from the Premier or the Regulator that the public record carries. The claimants who won their money hold orders instead. SecretsReporters has written to the claimants' counsel of record and to the High Court Registry seeking confirmation of what, if anything, was paid, and what enforcement steps followed the deadline, and the answers, when they come, will be reported. On the face of the record as it stands, the position is the one the judge forecast in September: the orders were made, the hour struck, and the bank that a court asked Nevis to close kept its doors open and its licence intact, with the penal notice still hanging over the directors who were told to pay.
SecretsReporters contacted BONI and the Nevis Financial Services Regulatory Commission for their responses to the findings in this report, but they gave no response as at the time of publishing.
Get every exclusive first. Follow Secrets Reporters on WhatsApp:
Follow Secrets Reporters on WhatsAppFollow Secrets Reporters on WhatsApp: join the channel for every exclusive the moment it publishes.

